Eye surgery and LASIK

Eye surgery, LASIK and ophthalmology malpractice.

When LASIK, cataract surgery or an eye exam goes wrong, the questions are what happened, whether a careful eye doctor would have done things differently, and which state’s rules apply. This guide explains how claims against ophthalmologists and optometrists generally work, what the FDA tells LASIK patients, and what to gather.

Editor:

Last updated November 2026

The short answer

Eye malpractice is a legal claim that an eye doctor’s care fell below the accepted standard and that the shortfall hurt the patient’s eye or vision. It can involve surgery, such as LASIK or cataract surgery, or everyday care, such as an eye exam where a disease was missed.

Two kinds of eye doctors are usually involved. The National Eye Institute (NEI), part of the National Institutes of Health, describes optometrists and ophthalmologists as the two basic types, and says an ophthalmologist may offer treatments, like surgery, that optometrists don’t (NEI: Finding an eye doctor). Which one treated you affects which law applies and which board licenses them.

A known risk isn’t proof of error: the FDA and NEI both list vision loss among the risks of eye surgery. The questions are whether the doctor met the standard of care, whether falling short caused the harm, and whether the claim is filed in time. An attorney licensed in the state where you were treated, usually working with an eye care expert, decides that.

We’re not a law firm, and we don’t evaluate anyone’s situation. See how our service works.

Concerns people raise about eye care

Questions about eye malpractice usually start with one of these problems. Each is a concern, not a conclusion:

  • LASIK and other laser vision surgery. Vision that is worse than before, glare, halos or double vision at night, severe dry eye, or vision that was over- or under-corrected. The FDA lists each of these as a risk of refractive surgery (FDA, LASIK risks).
  • Cataract surgery. NEI lists swelling, bleeding or infection, vision loss or double vision, unusual changes in eye pressure, retinal detachment and secondary cataracts among the risks (NIH, National Eye Institute: Cataract surgery).
  • A missed or late diagnosis. Glaucoma, a retinal tear or detachment, or another disease that wasn’t found, followed up or referred in time. NEI says glaucoma often has no early symptoms and that the only way to find out whether you have it is a comprehensive dilated eye exam (NEI: Glaucoma).
  • Follow-up, screening and consent. Pain, worsening vision or infection after surgery that wasn’t treated quickly, or risks no one explained before an elective procedure.

A poor result alone doesn’t settle anything. NEI says the problems it lists after cataract surgery can be treated, ideally as soon as possible (NIH, National Eye Institute: Cataract surgery). So attorneys look at what happened after a complication appeared, not only at the complication. For the general distinction, see surgical complication vs. surgical error, and for missed diagnoses, diagnosis concerns.

Sudden vision changes need care now

NEI calls retinal detachment a medical emergency and says to go to your eye doctor or the emergency room right away for symptoms such as a lot of new floaters, flashes of light, or a shadow or curtain over your vision (NEI: Retinal detachment). After LASIK, the FDA says to contact your doctor immediately for severe pain or vision that gets worse instead of better (FDA, before, during and after LASIK). Call 911 in an emergency.

LASIK: what the FDA tells patients

The FDA describes LASIK as a procedure that permanently changes the shape of the cornea, the clear covering of the front of the eye, using an excimer laser. A flap is cut in the cornea and folded back while the laser removes tissue underneath (FDA, LASIK). The FDA’s patient pages show what it expects patients to be told and screened for.

  • The risks it names. “Some patients lose vision.” Others develop glare, halos or double vision that can seriously affect night vision, or severe dry eye that may be permanent. Patients may be under- or over-treated and still need glasses. The FDA adds that long-term safety and effectiveness aren’t known (FDA, LASIK risks).
  • Who may not be a good candidate. The FDA lists people whose prescription changed in the past year, people with diseases or medications that can affect healing, and anyone under 18. It says a doctor should screen for large pupils, thin corneas, eyelid inflammation and dry eye, and warns that surgery on a cornea that is too thin may cause blinding complications (FDA, when LASIK is not for you).
  • The conversation before surgery. The FDA says your doctor should do a thorough eye exam and discuss whether you’re a good candidate and the risks, benefits and alternatives, and that you should have time to ask questions before signing the informed consent form (FDA, before, during and after LASIK). Its checklist suggests asking whether the doctor gave you a consent form to take home (FDA, LASIK checklist).
  • Advertising. The FDA tells patients to be wary of eye centers that advertise “20/20 vision or your money back” or package deals. It says the doctor should give you the laser maker’s patient handbook and be willing to discuss their own outcomes (FDA, LASIK risks).

The FDA’s role has limits. It regulates the sale of the lasers used for LASIK, but it says it doesn’t have authority to regulate a doctor’s practice or to recommend individual doctors or eye centers (FDA, LASIK: FDA’s role). How a surgeon screened, informed and treated a patient is a question of state law.

Is eye malpractice treated as medical malpractice?

The answer starts with who treated you. The FDA’s LASIK glossary defines an ophthalmologist as “a medical doctor specializing in the diagnosis and medical or surgical treatment of visual disorders and eye disease,” and an optometrist as “a primary eye care provider” (FDA, LASIK glossary). Both states below put claims against physicians under their malpractice statutes. Optometrists are licensed under separate laws, so the question for them is whether those statutes include them too. Two examples, from the statute text:

  • Florida defines a “health care provider” for its medical negligence rules to include “any person licensed under chapter 458, chapter 459, chapter 460, chapter 461, chapter 462, chapter 463” and other listed chapters (Fla. Stat. § 766.202(4)). Chapters 458 and 459 license physicians and osteopathic physicians (Fla. Stat. § 458.328), and chapter 463 is Florida’s optometry law, whose board is the Board of Optometry (Fla. Stat. § 463.002). That law also states: “Surgery of any kind is expressly prohibited,” with narrow exceptions such as removing superficial foreign bodies (Fla. Stat. § 463.014(4)).
  • Ohio names optometrists in its malpractice limitations statute. It covers “a medical, dental, optometric, or chiropractic claim,” and defines an optometric claim as one against an optometrist, or an optometrist’s employee or agent, that “arises out of the optometric diagnosis, care, or treatment of any person.” A medical claim includes one against a physician, defined as a person licensed to practice medicine and surgery or osteopathic medicine and surgery by the state medical board (Ohio Rev. Code § 2305.113).

Other states write their own definitions and set their own limits on what optometrists may do. An attorney licensed in your state can confirm which rules cover each person and business involved, including a surgery center.

Deadlines for an eye malpractice claim

Every state sets a malpractice deadline, and some require steps before a lawsuit. See medical malpractice deadlines by state and pre-suit requirements by state.

Ohio’s statute shows how a deadline can work when it names eye doctors directly. The same rules apply to medical and optometric claims:

  • An action must generally be commenced within one year after the cause of action accrued.
  • If, before that year ends, the claimant gives written notice to the person who is the subject of the claim that an action is being considered, the action may be commenced within 180 days after the notice.
  • No action may be commenced more than four years after the act or omission, with exceptions the statute spells out, including for injuries that couldn’t reasonably have been discovered sooner and for foreign objects left in the body (Ohio Rev. Code § 2305.113).

Vision problems can develop slowly, so note when each symptom started and when you learned of a diagnosis, and ask an attorney licensed in your state which deadline applies.

Licensing boards and complaints

Ophthalmologists are licensed by the state medical board, and in some states a separate osteopathic board. Our guide lists every state’s medical board, license lookup and complaint page.

Optometrists are licensed by a separate state board of optometry or vision professionals. Three examples:

A complaint is not a claim. A board acts on the license, not on your losses. Florida’s Department of Health says its actions against practitioners are administrative, such as a reprimand, fine, probation, or license suspension or revocation, and that “The Department cannot represent you in civil matters to recover fees paid or seek remedies for injuries” (Florida Department of Health). A legal claim has its own deadline, which keeps running whether or not you file a complaint.

Problems with the laser. The FDA asks people reporting LASIK problems through MedWatch, its safety reporting program, to include the specific name of the laser and its manufacturer (FDA, LASIK: Report a problem; FDA MedWatch). That report is separate from any legal claim.

What an attorney looks at

  • Screening. For elective surgery, what the preoperative measurements and exam showed, and whether the conditions the FDA says a doctor should screen for were checked.
  • Consent. What you were told and what you signed. Florida’s Medical Consent Law, for example, covers physicians and osteopathic physicians and asks whether a reasonable person would have had a general understanding of the procedure, the medically acceptable alternatives and the substantial risks. A signed written consent meeting its terms raises a rebuttable presumption that consent was valid (Fla. Stat. § 766.103(3)–(4)). Optometrists aren’t among the licensees it names.
  • The procedure. The operative report, the device or lens used, and anything noted as unexpected during surgery.
  • Who did what. Eye surgery often involves more than one provider. The FDA notes that pre- and post-operative care for LASIK may be provided by a doctor other than the surgeon (FDA), and the Texas Optometry Board says a therapeutic optometrist may provide pre- and post-op care for laser surgery (Texas Optometry Board).
  • Follow-up. When symptoms were reported, what was done, and how quickly. In missed-diagnosis cases, what earlier exams recorded and whether you were sent on to another doctor.
  • The harm. Lasting vision loss, further surgery, and effects on driving, work and daily life.

An attorney usually has an eye care expert review the records before taking a case, and some states require that review before a lawsuit. Attorneys decline cases for many reasons; see why attorneys turn down medical malpractice cases.

What to gather

  • Your eye care records, including exam notes, test results and measurements, from every eye doctor involved. Federal law gives you a right to a copy of your health information, and a covered provider generally must act on your request within 30 days (45 C.F.R. § 164.524).
  • Surgery paperwork: consent forms, any patient booklet, ads or quotes, the operative report and discharge instructions.
  • Device details: for LASIK, the name of the laser and its manufacturer; for cataract surgery, the type of artificial lens implanted.
  • Old glasses and contact lens prescriptions, which show how your vision changed over time.
  • A timeline of visits, calls, symptoms and what you were told. Our timeline worksheet can help.
  • Records of later care from any other eye doctor, retina doctor or emergency room.

Keep these yourself and share them with your own attorney. For help with requests, see how to get your medical records.

Sources and corrections

We wrote this page from the primary sources below and checked it against them on November 13, 2026.

We are not attorneys, and this page is not legal advice. Laws change and differ from state to state. If anything here is out of date or wrong, email support@malpracticeattorneys.com with the page name, and we’ll review it and update the page.

Questions

Questions about eye surgery malpractice.

Can you sue for a bad LASIK result?

A disappointing result isn’t enough on its own, because the FDA lists vision loss, glare, halos, severe dry eye and under- or over-correction among the known risks of LASIK. A claim usually turns on whether the surgeon screened you properly, explained the risks, performed the surgery with care and responded to problems afterward. An attorney, usually working with an eye care expert, decides whether the records support that. Deadlines apply.

Can you sue for cataract surgery complications?

Complications such as infection, swelling or retinal detachment are listed risks of cataract surgery, so the question is how the surgery was done and how quickly problems were recognized and treated. NEI says treatment for these problems should start as soon as possible, which is why the timing of follow-up visits and calls often matters. An attorney reviews the operative report and follow-up records with an expert.

Can you sue an optometrist for missing glaucoma or a detached retina?

In some states, yes: Florida and Ohio both include optometrists in their malpractice statutes. Whether a missed diagnosis supports a claim depends on what the exams showed, what a careful eye doctor would have done, and whether earlier treatment would have changed the outcome. NEI says glaucoma treatment can stop damage from getting worse but won’t undo it, so dates of exams and diagnosis matter.

Do I need an eye malpractice attorney in my state?

A claim follows the law of the state where the care happened, so you’ll want an attorney licensed there. That state’s statutes decide whether the eye doctor counts as a health care provider, which deadline applies and what steps come before a lawsuit. We’re not a law firm; to learn how our service connects people with participating attorneys, see how it works.

Questions about eye surgery or eye care?

Tell us what happened in a few short questions. Approximate dates are fine, and you don’t need your records to start.

Requests aren’t open yet: get notified

Our service is free. No obligation to hire. Attorney advertising. Not a law firm.